Updated Nov 5, 2026· 8 min read

Key takeaways

  • Bed bug and dust mite worries: Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth or SureGuard encasement.
  • Allergy-sensitive sleepers: AllerEase Maximum Allergy Protection.
  • Kids, pets, and midnight accidents: Utopia Bedding Waterproof.
  • Organic-minded buyers: Naturepedic Organic Waterproof.
  • Owners who rotate or move the mattress often: a fitted protector is easier to handle than a zipped encasement, so start with Utopia Bedding or Naturepedic.
  • Rental or secondhand bed purchases where pests are a worry: a full encasement such as SureGuard adds a barrier on every side.
  • Shoppers who want to compare general waterproof styles: see our best mattress protector waterproof guide.

Imagine a dense memory foam mattress that was a serious purchase, and then a toddler, a spilled glass of water, or a pet accident lands on it in the middle of the night. Foam of that kind soaks up liquid and dries slowly, which is why a cover is the first accessory most owners of a Tempur-Pedic bed shop for. The right cover keeps the surface clean and the warranty intact without changing how the foam feels under your body.

The hard part is choosing one that fits and does not fight the foam. A bed of this type is often tall, and a cover that is too shallow pops off the corners, while a stiff plastic-backed cover can turn the surface crinkly and warm. This guide lists five covers and encasements from well-known protector brands and explains what to check. As of 2026, the safest approach is still to confirm the depth range on the listing before you order, because none of these names states compatibility on its own.

Quick Picks

Product Best for Worth knowing
Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Encasement Full enclosure of the mattress An encasement, and the name says Smooth and Zip
SureGuard Mattress Encasement Buyers who want the whole mattress wrapped Sold as an encasement, not a topper
AllerEase Maximum Allergy Protection Mattress Protector Allergy-conscious households Allergy protection is part of the name
Utopia Bedding Waterproof Mattress Protector Everyday spill and accident cover Waterproof is stated in the name
Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector Buyers who prefer organic-labeled products Organic and waterproof are both in the name

How to Choose

Pocket depth for a tall foam mattress

Premium foam beds are often 10 to 13 inches tall, sometimes more, so a standard 14 inch pocket may be tight and a cover with a stated range up to 16 inches or more is safer. Measure the mattress from bed to top edge with a tape measure before you shop, and add about 1 inch of margin so the elastic skirt can seat fully under the corners.

Encasement versus fitted protector

A fitted protector covers the top and sides with a skirt and leaves the bottom open. An encasement zips around all six sides. Encasements are common in allergy and bed bug protection, but the zipper must be closed fully and never forced. If you only want to guard the sleeping surface, a fitted protector is simpler to put on and take off.

Breathability and noise

Dense foam already holds warmth, so a cover that traps more heat will make the bed feel hotter. Look for a soft knit or terry surface over a thin waterproof membrane rather than a heavy plastic-feeling sheet, and avoid covers that crinkle when you shift. Quiet fabrics let the foam keep its contouring feel. A quick check is to press your palm into the cover and slide it: a fabric that drags or squeaks against your hand will do the same against your shoulder at night. Hot sleepers should also favor lighter colors and thinner membranes, which let heat escape more readily.

Care instructions and warranty

Choose a cover that is machine washable on a warm or cold cycle, because heat can degrade waterproof membranes. Before buying, read the foam maker’s warranty language, since stains can void coverage and some makers specify what kind of protector is acceptable. If a spill occurs, blot rather than rub, and let the foam air dry fully. Never use a hair dryer on high heat or a steam cleaner on dense foam, because heat can break the cells down and leave a permanent soft spot. Keep the receipt and photos of the protector in place in case you need to document care for a warranty claim.

Our Picks Reviewed

Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Encasement

The name describes a zippered encasement with a smooth surface. Pro: a full encasement surrounds the mattress on all sides, which gives the broadest protection against spills, dust, and pests in the category. Pro: Protect-A-Bed is a protector-focused brand, so product information is usually easy to find. Con: encasements are fiddly to install on a heavy foam mattress, since the zipper needs the mattress to be fully tucked in, and two people are usually needed. The name does not state a depth range, so verify it against your mattress height. Skip it if you want a quick on-and-off cover for frequent washing, or if you prefer a fitted style with an open bottom. Because encasements wrap the mattress completely, plan to install one right when the bed arrives, while it is still easy to lift, and keep the zipper tab protected so it does not snag the fabric.

SureGuard Mattress Encasement

SureGuard is sold as a mattress encasement, which means full enclosure on every side. Pro: wrapping the whole mattress is a common approach for people worried about bed bugs and allergens as well as spills. Pro: an encasement avoids the loose-skirt problem that tall mattresses cause with fitted covers, since the zipper holds the cover in place. Con: wrestling a dense foam mattress into an encasement is a chore, and a stiff zipper can snag if the fabric is pinched. Confirm the stated height range matches your bed before ordering. Skip it if you rotate your mattress often, if you wash covers weekly, or if you want a lighter, simpler layer. Before wrapping a dense bed, also read the mattress maker’s care notes, since some makers ask owners not to compress or fold the foam during handling.

AllerEase Maximum Allergy Protection Mattress Protector

The name puts allergy protection first. Pro: it is aimed at households dealing with dust mites and similar triggers, which fits owners of any thick foam mattress who want a barrier around the surface. Pro: a protector from a mainstream household brand is widely stocked and easy to replace when it wears out. Con: the name does not mention pocket depth or waterproofing, so read the listing closely to learn whether it handles liquids as well as allergens. Skip it if your main worry is spills and accidents rather than allergies, or if you need a documented depth range for a very tall mattress. Wash according to the label to preserve any protective finish. Households with children or pets should add a second, waterproof layer on top so one cover handles allergens while the other handles accidents, and either can be washed without the other.

Utopia Bedding Waterproof Mattress Protector

This is a straightforward waterproof protector. Pro: waterproof is stated in the name, so it directly addresses the biggest risk to foam: absorbed liquid. Pro: Utopia Bedding focuses on affordable basics, so it is an easy choice for a guest room or a bed that sees frequent accidents. Con: waterproof layers can add warmth and a faint rustle, so check how the top fabric feels and whether it is described as quiet. Confirm the pocket depth before you buy, as the name does not state it. Skip it if you want a premium fabric feel on top of a premium mattress, or if you prefer natural fibers. A simple way to judge the fit is to pull the cover over a corner before removing the packaging fully, since a skirt that barely reaches the underside of the foam will creep upward as you move.

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector

Organic and waterproof are both in the name, which targets shoppers who care about materials. Pro: it combines liquid protection with an organic claim, a combination that is not easy to find in this product type. Pro: Naturepedic is known for focusing on organic bedding, so the brand fits buyers who want a consistent approach across their sleep products. Con: specialty positioning usually means a higher purchase cost than basic polyester protectors, and the name gives no depth range. Verify the stated height and read the care label before washing. Skip it if you are on a tight budget or if you only need a basic, replaceable layer for a short-term bed. Organic-labeled materials also deserve a quick look at the certificate named on the product page, so the label means something beyond marketing.

Which One Fits

  • Bed bug and dust mite worries: Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth or SureGuard encasement.
  • Allergy-sensitive sleepers: AllerEase Maximum Allergy Protection.
  • Kids, pets, and midnight accidents: Utopia Bedding Waterproof.
  • Organic-minded buyers: Naturepedic Organic Waterproof.
  • Owners who rotate or move the mattress often: a fitted protector is easier to handle than a zipped encasement, so start with Utopia Bedding or Naturepedic.
  • Rental or secondhand bed purchases where pests are a worry: a full encasement such as SureGuard adds a barrier on every side.
  • Shoppers who want to compare general waterproof styles: see our best mattress protector waterproof guide.

Common Mistakes

  1. Buying a cover without measuring the mattress height first.
  2. Choosing a thick plastic-backed protector that traps heat on a foam bed.
  3. Forcing an encasement zipper instead of tucking the mattress in fully.
  4. Washing waterproof covers on a hot cycle and drying on high heat.
  5. Skipping the protector until after the first spill, when the foam is already damaged and the warranty may no longer apply.

FAQ

Will a cover change how a memory foam mattress feels?

A thin knit cover barely changes the feel, while a thick quilted pad adds cushioning. For a quilted layer, read about mattress pad protectors and decide whether you want the extra softness.

Does a mattress cover affect the warranty?

Usually it helps, since stains can void coverage. Always read the foam maker’s instructions to confirm which protector types are acceptable.

Can I use a standard fitted sheet protector on a tall mattress?

Only if the pocket depth exceeds the mattress height. Otherwise the corners pull up and the cover slips.

How often should the cover be washed?

Every one to two months is a common routine, plus right after any spill. Follow the care label to avoid damaging the waterproof layer, and line-dry or use low heat so the membrane keeps sealing properly through repeated washes.

Is an encasement better than a fitted protector?

It offers broader coverage, but a fitted protector is easier to install and launder. Pick based on whether pests or everyday spills are the bigger concern.

D
Disdik Picks Editorial Team
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.

More from Amazon

Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.

Subscribe & Save

Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.

Explore Subscribe & Save
Amazon Wedding Registry

Collect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.

Create a wedding registry
Amazon Prime

Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Start a Prime free trial
Audible

Audiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Try Audible free

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.